What to ask before replacing a nurse call system
Buying guides · · 6 min read
A nurse call replacement is a big project: hardware in every room, an install that touches the whole building, and a system your community will likely run for a decade or more. It's worth slowing down before signing anything, because most of the expensive mistakes in this category happen before the contract, not after.
One thing worth knowing before any of the questions below: a working call system isn't optional in a skilled nursing facility. Federal regulation requires it in plain terms: residents must be able to reach staff through a system that relays the call directly from their bedside and from toilet and bathing facilities.
Whatever you replace it with has to keep meeting that bar.
What is this system actually for?
A nurse call system exists for one job: a resident presses a button, and someone finds out fast. Everything else a vendor demos, the reporting dashboards, the staff messaging, the integrations, is built on top of that one job. Before you evaluate any of it, get clear on what you're actually trying to fix.
If the real complaint is "call lights take too long to answer," that's a staffing and workflow question, and new hardware alone won't answer it. If the complaint is "the wiring is 20 years old and parts don't exist anymore," that's a real infrastructure problem a replacement solves directly. Most projects are a mix of both, and it's worth writing down, before any vendor calls, which part is which.
How much of what comes through it is actually an emergency?
Ask your own staff this question before you ask a vendor. In one study of 105 nursing home staff, 72% agreed that residents use call lights for non-urgent requests, and just over 49% said staff don't pay close attention to the light when it comes on.
A separate hospital survey of nearly 800 nursing staff found toileting assistance was the single leading reason patients used their call light at all, ordinary care, not crisis.
That's not a staffing failure so much as a signal problem: when a system carries both "I need help right now" and "I need help getting to the bathroom" on the same button, the people answering it learn to discount it.
A new call system won't fix that by itself. Ask any vendor directly: does this system distinguish between an emergency and a routine request, or does everything ring the same way? If the answer is "everything rings the same," you're paying for new hardware to carry the same mixed signal the old system carried.
What happens to a request once it's answered?
Ask to see what happens after a light goes on and someone responds. In a lot of systems, the honest answer is: nothing. The light turns off, and there's no record that a request happened, what it was for, or whether it actually got resolved. Observational research in four nursing homes found staff cancelled call lights due to workload about 10% of the time, and forgot to return to the resident roughly 3% of the time, with an average response time of about 9 minutes.
In four hospitals, by contrast, nursing staff answered calls within an estimated 4 minutes on average, noticeably faster, worth asking a vendor to explain if their own numbers land closer to the slower end.
If a system can't tell you, a month from now, how many calls came from a specific room or how long the average response actually took, you're buying the same blind spot you already have, just with new hardware around it.
Who is this actually built for: the resident, or the facility?
Ask to see the resident-facing side, not just the staff dashboard. Some systems are built almost entirely around the staff workflow, with the resident's actual experience treated as an afterthought: a pull cord, a button, and nothing else.
It's worth asking because residents notice. A hospital survey of patients and family members found 53% believed most of their call-light use mattered to their own safety, and that answering it promptly should be a nursing priority.
Federal data on nursing home complaints goes further: failure to respond to a resident's request for assistance was the single most common complaint category that Long-Term Care Ombudsman programs handled nationally for over a decade, and residents filed 40% of those complaints themselves rather than through family or staff.
Whatever system you install, it's answering a question residents already care about enough to file a complaint over.
What does this system explicitly not do?
This is the question vendors answer least directly, and it's the one worth pushing hardest on. A nurse call system is not a maintenance ticketing tool, not a way to track dietary requests, and not a system of record for the dozens of non-emergency asks that reach staff every day through other channels entirely. Any vendor who implies otherwise, that their system will also solve your non-clinical request volume, is selling you a feature they haven't built yet.
The honest scope of a nurse call system is narrow: get a real emergency in front of a person fast. Everything a resident asks that isn't that, the thermostat, the meal, the ride to an appointment, needs somewhere else to go. Nurse call was never built for it, and that's fine.
One hospital study found that structured hourly staff rounds, not new call-light hardware, were what actually reduced call-light use and improved patient safety and satisfaction, a reminder that the fix for "too many calls" is often a process change sitting next to the system, not inside it.
The decision this actually is
A nurse call replacement is worth doing when the current system genuinely can't do its one job anymore: it's unreliable, it's undocumented, or the hardware is failing. It's worth being skeptical when a replacement is being pitched as a fix for a problem that was never really about the call button in the first place, staff being buried in non-urgent requests with nowhere clear to send them.
Those are two different projects, and they call for two different answers. Getting clear on which one you actually have is worth more than any feature comparison.
Buttonworks doesn't replace a nurse call system, and isn't an emergency service. It handles the everyday requests that reach staff outside of it. See how the two work together on the nurse call comparison page.
Sources
- 42 CFR § 483.90(g), Requirements for Long-Term Care Facilities, enforced by CMS as a condition of Medicare and Medicaid participation. The current, active federal regulation requiring a working resident call system.
- Ali H, Cole A, Sienkiewicz A, Ho T. Perspectives of Nursing Homes Staff on the Nature of Residents-Initiated Call Lights. SAGE Open Nursing, 2020. Survey of 105 staff at one nursing home.
- Tzeng HM. Perspectives of staff nurses of the reasons for and the nature of patient-initiated call lights: an exploratory survey study in four USA hospitals. BMC Health Services Research, 2010. 808 nursing staff, 27 units across 4 Midwestern hospitals. 52% said patient-initiated calls required the attention of nursing staff, so nearly half did not. Hospital setting, not senior living.
- Ali H, Li H. Use of Notification and Communication Technology (Call Light Systems) in Nursing Homes. J Med Internet Res, 2020. Observational study in 4 nursing homes.
- Tzeng HM. Perspectives of patients and families about the nature of and reasons for call light use and staff call light response time. Medsurg Nursing, 2011. 63 patients and family members, hospital setting.
- Nguyen K, Downie S, White E. Protecting Rights and Preventing Abuse: Handling Resident Complaints in Long-Term Care Facilities. NORC at the University of Chicago, prepared for the Administration for Community Living, 2019. National Ombudsman Reporting System data, FFY2017, 144,003 nursing home complaints.
- Meade CM, Bursell AL, Ketelsen L. Effects of nursing rounds: on patients' call light use, satisfaction, and safety. American Journal of Nursing, 2006. Hospital medical-surgical units; the basis for hourly-rounding protocols now used in some skilled nursing facilities too.
Every statistic in this guide is cited on the Sources page. See more guides.